Talk:Throwback/@comment-148.101.158.234-20170512231219/@comment-2601:544:C102:12BF:399C:DF0A:F771:62C4-20180305183805

Not necessarily, Ice Power in the 64 increases your attack against fire enemies by two instead of one. In TTYD the badge gives you 1 more power and defense against fire enemies. So if you used both badges in the 64 version it wouldn't be the same since you'll get one more attack. Plus the challenge is based on using anything with the same names across both games, since Fire Shield isn't in TTYD you wouldn't be allowed to use it.